It's interesting to see this kind of attitude from a professional. I wonder if she has researched the different reading and writing apps to find that iPads aren't only for "play," but rather have been designed for individialized learning and interaction.
If you have seen a 3 or 4 year old use an iPad, you realize that they are learning problem solving and are fullly engaged in process learning as they figure out how to go back and forth on the iPad.
Still, that shouldn't stop parents and preschools from urging kids to learn to write the old-fashioned way—with pencil and paper, instead of pushing a button or swiping the screen on an iPad, Dinehart said. In a column published Tuesday on cnn.com, she provides tips on how to get kids to write, including keeping lots of crayons, markers and sidewalk chalk around the house.
"It's not realistic to say that [kids] are not going to play with electronics at all, but one shouldn't replace the other," Dinehart said
The way that she says play indicates that she doesn't realize the deep impact that play plays into literacy development. It's in those games of restaurant where kids are writing down orders or reading a menu that kids develop the real world need for literacy.
It's in writing the grocery list with a parent that kids learn literacy.
All of these may be considered play, but a love of literacy starts with playing with words and writing.
Sure I want my students to do well on a 2nd grade standardized test, but more than that, I want them to love language for the rest of their lives.
So maybe a device that lets you "play" with words is really the best way to engage emergent readers and writers.